Should A 6 Year Old Be Taking Structured Piano Lessons

Should A 6 Year Old Be Taking Structured Piano Lessons

We got this one wrong.

One of my favorite perks to owning a music school is when I have a moment of connection with a parent that really gets me thinking about what we do as music educators, and why we do it.

Today was one of those moments.

A parent reached out to let us know that their 6 year old wasn’t going to continue with piano lessons. After a few months they felt it just wasn’t the right time, and that their child might be better off taking a break and simply enjoying music without the pressure of structured lessons.

And you know what, I agree with them.

In this case, I think we got it wrong.

We followed too many rules and “norms”

This happens from time to time. But I also think it’s an opportunity for us to look a little deeper at our team, our teaching practices, what we’re offering and whether we’re really doing what’s best for the student. I think we owe that to the families who trust us with their children’s musical education.

Here’s the question. Should a 6 year old be put into rigorous, structured piano lessons?

If you ask me that question 100 times, I’m going to say no 100 times.

I’m not trying to pick a fight with the establishment here. I’m sure most traditionally trained piano teachers would probably think my methods are whacked right out. LOL.

But that’s where I’m coming from.

I’ve been doing this for over 36 years and have had the privilege of working with thousands of young musicians. And the longer I do this, the deeper I believe that our biggest responsibility as educators is to help people develop a beautiful relationship with music. Everything else comes after that.

We have to remember that up until a certain age, kids don’t really know why they’re doing what they’re doing. They generally just do what we tell them to do. We tell them to sit at the piano, play these notes, read this music, practice this piece, do it again until you get it right.

We point out all the mistakes and flaws in an effort to “teach them the proper way”

And sure, some kids absolutely thrive in that environment. But many, if not most do not.

How many kids are just doing it because that’s what the adults in their lives expect them to do?

And how many end up walking away from music altogether because somewhere along the way it stopped being fun?

That’s what concerns me. Kids that “quit” music often associate with being a bad musician Or not having Musical “talent”

And do I EVER despise the word talent🤬

As most of you reading this already know, I have identical twin 7 year old daughters and people are always surprised when I tell them that they’ve only had one official music lesson in their lives. It was with the absolutely fabulous Rocky Riobo, a creative ball of energy gifted to our Music school. See the picture of the actual moment I’m referring to and how happy we all look after the lesson finished.

And that lesson with Rocky was spent writing a song they wanted to write called “Dead Rat” based on a true story. LOL. I have a recording if you want to hear it. The spark and the memory of that moment are forever etched in my mind because we recorded it ,because they created it because it was something that hadn’t existed before.

I’m incredibly protective of their enjoyment of music. Celebrating the unique way they want to experience it.

We sing, dance, make up goofy songs, experiment with sounds and just have fun. They genuinely believe that I think their music is the greatest music in the world, and I’m going to keep letting them believe that.

Because that’s what I want for them. I want them to own their relationship with music. Not do it because Dad thinks they should.

I also think we sometimes underestimate how much we can do as parents without any formal musical training ourselves.

Celebrate the music your child loves. Even if you think it’s terrible, act like it’s the greatest thing you’ve ever heard. Get them a keyboard that makes crazy sounds, let them explore a synthesizer, sit them behind a drum kit and blast their favourite songs while you jump around showing them how cool it is. If you’ve got an iPad, open GarageBand and let them make their own music.

Let them make noise. Let them create something that makes absolutely no sense to us. Who cares? It’s their music.

And please don’t feel that everything they do musically needs to be corrected or turned into a lesson.

There’s lots of time for that.

One of my biggest missions in life is to improve access to music education and its transformative benefits. I believe music should be available to everybody, regardless of their unique circumstances.

And I know there’s irony in a music school owner telling people they don’t necessarily need music lessons.

But I fundamentally believe that.

If you’re a parent reading this and perhaps you can’t afford music lessons, or you’re wondering whether your young child is ready for lessons, I hope there’s something of value here that you can bring into your own house.

You don’t need an expensive instrument, a music degree or a weekly lesson to start building a love of music in your child.

You can do so much just by encouraging them, listening to them and celebrating whatever they create.

Sometimes the best thing we can do as parents and educators is recognizing that perhaps it’s not the right time for structured lessons. Or maybe the approach needs to change. Maybe instead of learning someone else’s music, the child would be happier creating their own.

I love witnessing when kids make up their own crazy abstact and sometimes even “musical” music. There’s something so pure about it. No rules, no right or wrong, just this incredible ability to explore and express themselves. And as they say, even a broken clock is right twice a day😂

I could go on and on about this. It’s something I’m obviously very passionate about.

I’m not suggesting I’ve got all the answers. Far from it. I’m still learning, and conversations like this are part of that process.

At the end of the day, I don’t care if a child becomes a concert pianist, a professional musician or just someone who loves singing along in the car.

What I care about is that they love music.

Because life’s too short to learn music you don’t love❤️🎵



Kris Schulz
Founder
Horizon School Of Music

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed

Student Login